I Used to Counteroffer My Best Employees With More Money. Now I Rely on These 3 Strategies.

Opinions expressed by Entrepreneur contributors are their own.
Like all business leaders, I have had some of my top performers tell me they were leaving. There is no way to sugarcoat the feeling. It’s like a kick in the belly — and in the wallet.
According to statistics reported by HR Morning, replacing an employee costs upwards of 200% of what they were making. And that is probably a conservative figure, given that losing a valuable team member can cause a ripple of lowered productivity and tabled projects as people scramble to pick up the ex-employee’s work.
Given these facts, I used to follow the standard pattern of attempting to keep talented team members by offering them higher compensation, bonuses or company equity. It was a tactic that almost always worked, but it didn’t create loyalty. Instead, it made those people price-sensitive, and they eventually found organizations willing to pay more, so they left anyway.
I am not suggesting that it is wrong to counteroffer someone’s resignation with money. However, it’s reactive and arbitrary. Unless you have put a cap on how high you are willing to go, your negotiations will begin to feel like a moving target that’s out of your control. Again, you may end up delaying someone’s departure, but you won’t keep them forever unless you put more proactive measures in place.
Some positions in your company drive enterprise value and some don’t. McKinsey and Company suggested in an older article that these will probably make up about 5% of your workforce — and contribute 800% more than others across your organization.
- Key Takeaways
- 1. Pinpoint which roles bring the most profit to your business
- 2. Rethink giving away equity
- 3. Develop financial-based retention tools
- Rashan Dixon • Co-founder of Techincon and Senior Business Consultant for Microsoft
Opens the original publisher's full article in a new tab with full editorial credit.
Takeaway for U.S. Small Business Owners
- Economic, SBA, and local consumer shifts hit hardest when a business relies purely on word-of-mouth or high-fee ad platforms.
- Owning a fast website, strong Google Business Profile, and clear local SEO captures high-intent customers searching right now.
Add NextRankHQ as a Preferred Source to see more of our search, AI, and small business operator briefings in Google Search & AI Overviews.
Briefing syndicated via public RSS feed from Entrepreneur Magazine for informational commentary. Full article copyright belongs to the original publisher.